5 Best Dog Training Collars of 2020 – Review & Buying Guide


Dogs bark. That’s just a fact of life for your canine companions. It’s how they communicate with you and with other dogs; it’s also a way for them to let off steam or show their excitement. Sometimes the barking can get excessive, hence the need for dog training collars.

Most dogs bark for a specific reason. If you have identified that reason and still can’t get your dog to stop barking with positive commands, then noise training collars come in handy.

MODUS Ultrasonic Bark Control Device, Anti Barking DeviceDog Training...
WOLFWILL 100% Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training...
POP VIEW Dog Bark Collar for Small, Medium, Large Dogs, Anti Bark...
POP VIEW Bark Collar [New Version] Humanely Stops Barking with Sound &...
DogRook Rechargeable Bark Collar - Humane, No Shock Training Collar -...
MODUS Ultrasonic Bark Control Device, Anti Barking DeviceDog Training...
WOLFWILL 100% Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training...
POP VIEW Dog Bark Collar for Small, Medium, Large Dogs, Anti Bark...
POP VIEW Bark Collar [New Version] Humanely Stops Barking with Sound &...
DogRook Rechargeable Bark Collar - Humane, No Shock Training Collar -...
MODUS Ultrasonic Bark Control Device, Anti Barking DeviceDog Training...
MODUS Ultrasonic Bark Control Device, Anti Barking DeviceDog Training...
WOLFWILL 100% Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training...
WOLFWILL 100% Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training...
POP VIEW Dog Bark Collar for Small, Medium, Large Dogs, Anti Bark...
POP VIEW Dog Bark Collar for Small, Medium, Large Dogs, Anti Bark...
POP VIEW Bark Collar [New Version] Humanely Stops Barking with Sound &...
POP VIEW Bark Collar [New Version] Humanely Stops Barking with Sound &...
DogRook Rechargeable Bark Collar - Humane, No Shock Training Collar -...
DogRook Rechargeable Bark Collar - Humane, No Shock Training Collar -...

Last update on 2020-06-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Now, you can’t use bark collars as a set-and-go type of device. The best collars on the market come with a way for you to control them remotely. This way, you actively train your dog rather than allow an object to do it for you.

When teaching your dog good behaviors using a training collar, always start it at the lowest setting no matter the correction method you use; whether you use noise or vibrations or both. If the lowest setting doesn’t work, gradually increase intensity.

When your dog stops barking after it hears a noise or feels a vibration, use positive reinforcement. Praise her and give her a treat so she associates her action with something good. Because the annoying or uncomfortable feeling from a training collar leaves a negative association with your dog, you don’t want her traumatized. Performing a positive action to accompany it can go a long way.

The Dog Digest does not recommend shock collars as they can become dangerous for many dogs. Many consider them inhumane, but a training collar with noise and vibrations can do a world of good.

Dogs also hear much differently than humans; they can hear excessively high pitches that we cannot. Those high pitches are often uncomfortable and frightening for a dog. If he can hear something you can’t, your dog will associate this sound with barking and be less apt to bark excessively.

Dogs can actually hear frequencies at 65,000 Hz, while humans can only hear frequencies up to 20,000 Hz, according to the American Kennel Club.

Knowing the features of each training collar, as well as the pros and cons, are essential when shopping for one. Get to know a little about the top ones on the market with the reviews below.

MODUS Ultrasonic Bark Control Device, Anti Barking DeviceDog Training...
  • DOG BARK CONTROL & DOG TRANING - Our ultrasonic anti bark device provides a safe and effective solution for dog training and bark control. The anti bark device can effectively train your dogs to stop...
  • SUITABLE FOR ALL SIZE DOGS - The average human hearing frequency range is 20HZ~20KHZ, and the dog can hear a wider range from 15HZ to 120KHZ. MODUS ultrasonic bark control emits ultrasonic sound at...
  • CONVENIENT TO USE OUTDOOR - MODUS ultrasonic barking dog deterrent just fits nicely in your hand and comes with an adjustable anti-static wrist strap. The control range of Modus bark deterrent is...

Last update on 2020-06-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Editor’s Comments

The Modus Ultrasonic Bark Control Device requires your attention and doesn’t just leave it up to the device to deliver its own high-pitch sound.

You control the noise frequency via a remote with just the press of a button. You’ll know it’s working via a green LED light. While this device sticks at one frequency, 25,000 Hz, your dog will hear it and should stop barking. Offer praise when he stops barking. This will make him happy and train him. He’ll soon associate barking with a sound he doesn’t like, plus your love and praise when he stops barking.

Pros

  • Allows you to control when a sound is emitted
  • Includes a green LED indicator

Cons

  • Only has a range of 16.4 feet
WOLFWILL 100% Waterproof Rechargeable Humane Remote Dog Training...
  • 100% WATERPROOF - IPX7 waterproof rating receiver with Durable ABS shell, TPU strap and tightly-sealed rubber plug on the charging hole, NO more worry about stepping into water, LET YOUR DOG ENJOY...
  • MULTIFUNCTION WIRELESS REMOTE - With LCD backlit display, 3 working modes: Tone, 1-16 levels of adjustable Vibration and Light, up to 660yard large control range in 433.92MHz frequency, able to...
  • SIMPLE BLIND OPERATION - Special Touch-distinguished Design of the 3 main buttons, easy identified button location that allows you to freely make any training demand without looking at the remote...

Last update on 2020-06-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Editor’s Comments

The Wolfwill Humane No-Shock Remote Dog Training Collar uses both noise and vibrations to stop your dog from barking. Unlike the Modus noise collar, this collar has 16 different intensity settings. As mentioned above, you always want to start at the lowest setting.

Your dog can hear the noise up to 660 yards. This collar might not only stop her from barking, but she may also learn to stay off furniture, as well as stop chewing on other items (such as your shoes or your kid’s homework).

Pros

  • Has 16 different settings
  • Easy touch control buttons
  • Waterproof
  • Uses both sound and vibrations

Cons

  • A bit bulky and may be uncomfortable for your dog

Last update on 2020-06-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Editor’s Comments

The POP VIEW Dog Anti-Bark Collar is best for the budget conscious and is designed to allow vibrations to reach even the thickest dog coats. It comes with seven different settings; of course, start with the lowest and see if that does the trick before increasing intensity.

However, this collar only works with loud barks and not with softer sounds your dog may make. This can prove either negative or positive. Many consider this a positive because it still allows your dog to make sounds without consequence. Remember, we don’t want to silence dogs; we just want to end excessive barking.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Seven different settings
  • Only picks up loud barks and doesn’t discourage every dog sound
  • Uses both sound and vibrations

Cons

  • Does not have remote control use
  • Does not fit well for small-breed dogs under 10 pounds
POP VIEW Bark Collar [New Version] Humanely Stops Barking with Sound &...
  • ✅Humanely silence your dog's annoying barking without painful, anxiety-causing shocks. Dogbark Intelligent no bark dog collar uses Painless sound and vibration stimuli to deter unwanted, annoying...
  • ✅No shock unit detects movement of your dog's vocal chords. It then emits Audible warning beeps that are followed by vibrations if the barking continues. Your dog will quickly and easily associate...
  • ✅Universal size is adjustable for your dog's neck. Suitable for all breeds and sizes, This anti bark collar can be worn indoors and outdoors for training consistency.

Last update on 2020-06-02 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Editor’s Comments

The POP View Human Bark Collar also uses both sound and vibrations and is ideal for the budget-conscious. It is not suitable for dogs under 10 pounds, but perfect for medium and larger dogs.

Unlike other collars, it does not come with a remote, but the vibrations are said to be more annoying than uncomfortable. It is not rechargeable like other bark collars but does come with a spare battery.

Pros

  • Affordable
  • Not too uncomfortable for your dog
  • Helps control barking within a few days of learning

Cons

  • Does not have remote control use
  • Does not fit well on small-breed dogs under 10 pounds
  • Sometimes too sensitive and picks up other surrounding noises
DogRook Rechargeable Bark Collar - Humane, No Shock Training Collar -...
  • HUMANE BARK COLLAR WITH 2 MODES - provides effective performance with sound (beeps) and 7 safe vibration modes. It helps your dog understand that barking not desirable. You can correct your dog's...
  • RECHARGEABLE VERSION - no bark collar works about 20 days with 1 battery life. Get full charge in 1-2 hours. Take all benefits with a new long-life battery.
  • FREE FROM REMOTE, AUTOMATICALLY STOP BARKING - You don’t have to waste your time anymore with this automatic bark collar. It helps your dog learn how to stop barking without your participation.

Last update on 2020-05-25 / Affiliate links / Images from Amazon Product Advertising API

Editor’s Comments

The DogRook Bark Collar is lightweight but strong and works well for both smaller and larger breed dogs. It comes with seven different settings of both sound and vibrations so you can start your dog out low and only gradually increase the sensations if necessary.

The DogRook is also not overly sensitive and will only pick up your dog’s bark and not other surrounding noise.

This dog training collar is waterproof so if you’re walking in the rain, no problem. It also comes with reflective striping on the collar to enhance safety during an evening walk in the dusk or dark.

Pros

  • Reflective strip
  • Waterproof
  • Not overly sensitive
  • Good for dogs of all sizes and breeds

Cons

  • Does not have remote control use
  • Not as many settings as other training collars

Our Pick

After trying different collars, The Dog Digest has decided The Wolfwill Humane No-Shock Remote Dog Training Collar gives you the most for your money, including training via both noise and vibrations.

First, the 16 different intensity settings allow you to start out at low frequencies and vibrations and very gradually increase. Ideally, you will never need to use the strongest settings. It also has a long-range remote control, meaning you can control your dog’s barking from other rooms in the house.

For a humane collar that you can control (rather than be controlled by your dog’s barking), The Wolfwill Humane No-Shock collar fits the bill. You and your dog will easily see its benefits.

Last Updated on

Kevin Bentley

Hi, I’m Kevin Bentley, a dog lover and enthusiast. Though I started out as a cat person, my wife quickly set me on the true path of dog love. Now I’m full-on obsessed with dogs and everything related to dogs. I’ve purchased every dog accessory you can think of, so I decided to collect my thoughts about them on this site.

Recent Content